Reviews For Gathering
Title: 1/1 Reviewer: Tigress Signed
Whoa! When you write angst, you go the whole nine yards, don't you? I would have appreciated a "character death" warning, but then, on the other hand, if you had provided one, I might not have read such a fine story. This was a stupendously angsty story, and extremely impressive for a beginning writer. The whole vampiric perversion of Giles' feelings for his Slayer and the others--that they will now be his new undead "family"--really grabbed at my emotions. The details added to the story, such as how Giles is warm because he just fed off of Willow, were also written very well. I hope you are going to write more BtVS stories in the future--although, just as my personal preference, I hope at least some of your future stories are a bit more upbeat!
Date: 17/06/05 - 10:00 pm [Report This]
Title: 1/1 Reviewer: Brent M Denny 21 Signed
I must say i really did like this story it was well thought out and setup and even though the seasons of Buffy had ended i do wonder if this had happened (Giles turning i mean) Would Buffy have been able to kill him in the series? Anyway 10/10 great first story and i look forward to reading more
Date: 09/06/05 - 03:00 pm [Report This]
Title: 1/1 Reviewer: Fairfax Signed
Am not usually keen on fics where characters get turned, but this is the exception. Think you did a really great job and created a strong atmosphere and moment in time for the action to take place within. Well done.
Date: 09/06/05 - 02:13 pm [Report This]
Title: 1/1 Reviewer: slay4you1978 Signed
I like your story, you did a good job for a beginner. I look forward to reading more of your stories.
Date: 09/06/05 - 05:45 am [Report This]